Quill & Pad
  • Home
  • Articles
  • About
  • Glossary
  • Contact
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu
You are here: Home1 / Watch Brands & Horology2 / Collectors and Collecting3 / Why We Are In A Golden Age For Appreciating Superlative Hand-Finishing...

Two faces, Two dials, Two identities

High performance escapement with
“triple pare-chute” protection

Limited edition of 10 pieces

Why We Are In A Golden Age For Appreciating Superlative Hand-Finishing In Wristwatches

by Ian Skellern

Looking at the entries in the 2015 Grand Prix d’Horlogerie de Genève, many of which had watch names seemingly longer than a feature article, I didn’t feel pressured to cut the title of this article short. But it really should have read: “Why we are in a golden age of appreciating fine hand-finishing. And why that might change relatively soon.”

I deliberately wrote “Why We Are In A Golden Age For Appreciating Superlative Hand-Finishing . . . ” because, the fact is that if many people do not appreciate superlative hand-finishing, then fewer will pay for superlative hand-finishing, so there is likely to be less superlative hand-finishing on offer.

Movement detail of the Philippe Dufour Duality

Movement detail of the Philippe Dufour Duality

We are in a golden age of appreciating superlative hand-finishing because . . .

We are in a golden age of appreciating superlative hand-finishing because of three factors, and these are all absolutely essential:

  • Audience (people to appreciate)
  • Information (knowledge is essential to appreciation)
  • Superlative hand-finishing included in some products (superlative as meaning “surpassing all else”)
Flat polished screw heads with polished bevels and countersinks visible through the display back of this Greubel Forsey Double Balancier

Flat polished screw heads with polished bevels and countersinks visible through the display back of this Greubel Forsey Double Balancier

Audience

It is absolutely no use making anything from a commercial perspective if nobody knows your product exists. And if something is not approached from at least a somewhat commercial perspective then we are unlikely to see much of the product. No matter how great the art or craft is, if the world doesn’t know it exists, then that art or craft is unlikely to thrive.

The internet has enabled a significant percentage of the world’s population access to relatively arcane and esoteric information like watches and horology. Thanks first to discussion forums, then blogs, and now social media, there is a potential global online audience for anything interesting, informative, or entertaining enough to catch our attention.

The internet has made a large appreciate audience for superlative hand-finishing possible. And the internet isn’t likely to be going anywhere soon, so this looks to remain a relatively stable factor in the future.

Mine at last: the Greubel Forsey Invention Piece 1 in red gold

Greubel Forsey Invention Piece 1 in red gold

Information

We have our potential audience, but it now needs to be educated to be an “appreciative” audience. And for that we have to thank the internet again. We (ourselves, brands, and even individual watchmakers) can share information among each other in real time (or not far off from it) using blogs and social media. And offline we have more magazines and events than ever before.

Then we have digital photography and smartphones, which have made sharing high-quality photos (even macro) and, more recently, videos relatively easily (though this still takes considerable practice to do well).

So thanks to the internet, digital photography, and smartphones we have an educated audience for appreciating wristwatches featuring “superlative hand-finishing.”

Kari Voutilainen Vingt-8 Sarasamon with dial from Unryuan studio in Japan. The Saiei Makie and Somata zaiku lacquering of this dial takes months to complete and uses gold dust), gold leaf, great green turban (a snail) shell and abalone shell from New Zealand

Kari Voutilainen Vingt-8 Sarasamon with dial from Unryuan studio in Japan

Superlative hand-finishing

Then there is the factor of the superlative hand-finishing itself. While opinions may differ − who am I kidding, opinions will certainly differ − I’d credit the launch of Philippe Dufour’s Simplicity and the Independent forum on ThePuristS (which was my horological home for many years) as bringing this subject to the attention of an (at the time nascent) global horological audience, including both excellence in finishing and why it’s something worthy of note.

While I know mentioning anyone is likely to annoy even more people not mentioned, in addition to the best hand-finishing from haute horlogerie brands like A. Lange & Söhne and Vacheron Constantin, we also have smaller players including Philippe Dufour, Kari Voutilainen, Jean Daniel Nicolas (Daniel Roth), Romain Gauthier, and Greubel Forsey to name just a few. These brands are ensuring that the knowledge of the craft of superlative hand-finishing burns brightly.

The stunning view through the display back of a Kari Voutilainen Observatoire

The stunning view through the display back of a Kari Voutilainen Observatoire

What could possibly go wrong?

So we have a large audience with easy access to information and quite a few watchmakers offering fantastic levels of finish. What could possibly go wrong? And why might that change?

One of the key factors (if not THE key factor) to note in this discussion is that at present, the very best hand-finished watch movements are the very best finished watch movements period.

The central flying tourbillon of the Haldimann H1

The central flying tourbillon of the Haldimann H1

Machines good, man better

Machines cannot finish watch components as finely, as subtly, or as distinctly as talented men and women with a file. And that’s down to one main technological constraint: the business end of machines (meaning the tools doing the milling or polishing) spin, rotating at high speed.

In comparison, human hand-finishing uses a reciprocal back and forth motion.

The rotary motion of machines means that small vertical lines can be seen on any machine-polished anglage, AND spinning tools cannot polish a sharp internal angle. Which is why so many brands that put emphasis on superlative hand-finish deliberately design movement bridges and plates to include multiple internal angles.

So until now, only the human touch offers the very best movement finishing.

Just a few of the critical points that have to be carefully hand finished on this lower constant force bridge for Romain Gauthier's Logical One

Just a few of the critical points that have to be carefully hand finished on this lower constant force bridge for Romain Gauthier’s Logical One

What if?

But what if that wasn’t the case in the future? What if somebody developed a CNC tool with a reciprocal motion? Then there would be no impediment to machines creating fine finishes at least to the stand of the best human hands and likely much better.

Superlatively hand-finished watches are expensive. Very expensive because hand-finishing is very labor-intensive and the skill is relatively rare.

But collectors, who both appreciate superlative hand-finishing and can afford it, can justify (at least partially) their purchases because they can be confident in having not just the best hand-finishing, but the best finishing altogether.

However, if − and I’m tempted to use “when” instead of “if” as it is surely just a matter of time − machines can finish better, can we be confident that as many collectors will be willing to pay as much for what is not no longer the world’s best finishing, but only the best hand-finishing?

I doubt it.

Vinyl records survive not (just) simply because of nostalgia, as powerful as that is, but because the quality of the music is significantly better than the mp3 format of most digital music. Whether the listener has a fine enough ear to hear or appreciate the difference between the music formats is neither here nor there. The fact is that records do offer (when partnered with a good turntable and amplifier) a much better quality sound than mp3.

Up close and personal: Philippe Dufour Duality dial

Up close and personal: Philippe Dufour Duality dial

Luxury: a mitigating factor?

Now, a few astute readers may bring up the very valid and pertinent point that watch brands are no longer selling the best of anything, but rather “luxury,” an altogether more intangible feature.

Even the very best modern mechanical wristwatches are nowhere near the accuracy or reliability of (much cheaper) quartz models. But the industry is thriving (at least over the medium to long term) because collectors are buying luxury rather than practicality.

And I get that. However, superlative hand finishing has become an essential factor in the highest-end timepieces, and if the meaning of superlative changes from “surpassing all else” to “surpassing all else except the ubiquitous mechanical finishes found on much cheaper watches” then I can’t help but feel that the appreciate audience that is so essential for superlative hand-finishing to maintain its present size is likely to shrink.

And if the audience − meaning potential market − shrinks, then the number of superlatively finished watches is likely to shrink, which will lead to fewer watchmakers and brands dedicating resources to creating the very best hand-finishing.

Which is why I think that we may be in a golden age for appreciating superlative hand-finishing in that we have the access, the information, and the hand-finished watches themselves.

Please note that I am not predicting the end of beautifully hand-finished watches, as there will (hopefully) always be a few watchmakers who will want to excel, but probably not as many as now. And there are not that many now.

Long may this golden period of hand-finishing last . . . because it is likely to come to an end, and the end may be sooner rather than later.

Exquisite tourbillon details of the Jean Daniel Nicolas Two-Minute Tourbillon by Mr. Daniel Roth. You can just make out the gold second hand on the left of tourbillon cage pointing to 60 and the blued-steel hand on the right pointing to 0.

Exquisite tourbillon details of the Jean Daniel Nicolas Two-Minute Tourbillon by Mr. Daniel Roth

To get an idea of what superlative hand finishing looks like, I encourage you to check out the following articles:
Does Hand Finishing Matter? A Collector’s View Of Movement Decoration
Why Philippe Dufour Matters. And It’s Not A Secret
Objects Of Desire: Greubel Forsey
Behind The Lens: Philippe Dufour Duality
Why I Bought It: Greubel Forsey Invention Piece 1
Why Do Ultra-High-End Watches Cost So Much? Hand-Finishing At Romain Gauthier Sheds Some Light

11 replies
  1. Stef
    Stef says:
    October 28, 2015 at 2:52 am

    This article begs many questions, but ultimately, I believe there will always be a desire for hand-made work. I think many covet high-end pieces because they are hand-made, not because hand-made necessarily produces the best possible result. Speaking of vinyl (why oh why did you open that can of worms;)), what many perceive as better sound is really due to minute imperfections in the medium – vinyl degrades and is altered over time (like with all analog information), and the signal path is inherently more lossy (vs CD) due to the longer analog chain. This is sort-of similar to collectors preferring the organic look of hand-applied Geneva stripes vs “perfect” machine striping. Collectors like unique things, things with character. This won’t change.

    (And FYI, I’ve never heard of anyone arguing vinyl vs mp3 – it’s always been vinyl vs CD, and an identically mastered CD is unarguably a more accurate representation of the artist’s studio performance compared to a vinyl record – and the gap only widens as the record ages).

    Reply
  2. Ian Skellern
    Ian Skellern says:
    October 28, 2015 at 5:54 pm

    Thank you for the thoughtful reply, Stef.

    I agree with you that there are sure to always be those who appreciate high-quality, handmade work and that are willing to pay for it. My point, though, was that those people may be much fewer in the not too distant future. I didn’t mean to sound the death knell for high-end hand-finishing, but to point out that we may well be in a golden age of appreciating high-end hand-finishing and that there may be less of it it the not-too-distant future.

    That said, as the world gradually (on average) gets wealthier, the increase in potential clients may mitigate or even outweigh the factors I highlight in this article.

    Regarding vinyl versus mp3 rather than CDs. I chose to compare vinyl with mps because:

    a. Most music today is being listened to as mp3 files rather than from CDs.

    b. The compression of mp3 files makes the sound quality noticeably poorer in comparison with vinyl (unlike with CDs as you point out).

    But do bear in mind that it does not matter if records are technically inferior to CDs, the fact that they are “perceived” to sound better is enough.

    Reply
    • Stef
      Stef says:
      October 29, 2015 at 6:13 am

      Agreeing with your last comment – it’s about perception, not measurable metrics. Also, should machine-finishing equal (or surpass!) the flourishes we value today, what constitutes superlative could very well change. E.g. with the advent of cameras, painters no longer aspire for photorealism.

      I guess I’m not arguing against the hypothesis of your article. This very well may be the beginning of a Golden Age of superlative finishing as we define superlative today.

      Reply
  3. Ed
    Ed says:
    October 28, 2015 at 9:12 pm

    Agreeing with the other commenter, vinyl is a technically inferior medium compared to compact disc. Compact discs simply have more dynamic range available because of the vinyl version must be carefully mixed to prevent the stylus from jumping out of the track. The move to compact disc gave audio engineers far more latitude in jumping quickly from soft to loud and back, which is part of the reason classical music sounds so much better on CD.

    Now, the loudness wars of the 1980s-present resulted in a reduction in dynamic range during the mastering process, so most popular music these days has been acoustically compressed to *not* have big jumps from soft to loud. This is purely a commercial/mixing decision and not technical flaw with mp3 or cd. Sometimes with modern releases the vinyl versions are from a different master that has not been made a victim of the loudness wars, the theory being that people buying vinyl these days are “audiophiles” and care about a better mix, while people buying cds/digital downloads want the same thing they would hear on the radio/in a club.

    Vinyl is in every technical way inferior to compact disc (and thus high-bitrate MP3, AAC, etc, since if you think you can reliably tell the difference between 320kbps mp3 and CD across a dozen random tracks in an a/b/x test I have a bridge to sell you). What most people like about vinyl are the flaws (the “warmth” from the background noise) and the misguided belief that they’re listening to a superior product. The only time the vinyl version is truly better is when it’s a different (better) mix than the digital version, and then you’re just comparing apples to oranges.

    Reply
    • Ian Skellern
      Ian Skellern says:
      October 29, 2015 at 11:08 am

      I never compared vinyl with CDs in the article but with mp3 files.

      Regards, Ian

      Reply
    • Stef
      Stef says:
      October 30, 2015 at 6:59 pm

      Can of worms: erupted.

      Reply
  4. David Wanstall
    David Wanstall says:
    June 9, 2019 at 11:02 am

    We insist on hand finishing now because all the other processes have already been automated. Automation opens the possibility of personalization thanks to on demand production at low cost. Assembly will also be automated. I think it will be a big issue for high end independents who produce hundreds of watches as the distinction will be between entirely hand made watches (Dufour, Roger Smith) and all the others. The upside of the whole process is a watch of the quality of entry level Blancpain or JLC for 2000 CHF if everything is automated and the watch is sold directly to the customer online without the cost of an AD. What might be bad for watchmakers, or watch finishers, will probably be good for most collectors.

    Reply

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Romain Gauthier Logical One – Watches With Style says:
    May 20, 2017 at 12:43 pm

    […] the great finishing has already been the subject of another article here on Quill & Pad (see Why We Are In A Golden Age For Appreciating Superlative Hand-Finishing In Wristwatches); and the striking ruby rollers on the movement’s chain, especially as seen on the early examples […]

    Reply
  2. Why I Bought It: Romain Gauthier Logical One (Archive) | Quill & Pad says:
    May 18, 2017 at 8:51 pm

    […] the great finishing has already been the subject of another article here on Quill & Pad (see Why We Are In A Golden Age For Appreciating Superlative Hand-Finishing In Wristwatches); and the striking ruby rollers on the movement’s chain, especially as seen on the early examples […]

    Reply
  3. Why I Bought It: Romain Gauthier Logical One | Quill & Pad says:
    May 30, 2016 at 6:08 pm

    […] the great finishing has already been the subject of another article here on Quill & Pad (see Why We Are In A Golden Age For Appreciating Superlative Hand-Finishing In Wristwatches); and the striking ruby rollers on the movement’s chain, especially as seen on the early examples […]

    Reply
  4. Lange Saxonia Boutique Ed. Vs. H Moser Venturer Small Seconds - Page 4 says:
    May 30, 2016 at 6:40 am

    […] That Patek picture is truly an eyesore. Can you give us a link to that article? There you go..Why We Are In A Golden Age For Appreciating Superlative Hand-Finishing In Wristwatches | Quill &… Reply With […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories

  • Watch Brands & Horology
    • New for 2025
    • New for 2024
    • New for 2023
    • Affordable Luxury
      • Swatch
      • Ball Watch
      • Louis Erard
      • Gorilla Fastback
      • Ikepod
      • Oris
      • Reservoir
    • Auctions
    • Behind the Lens
    • Boutiques
    • Collectors and Collecting
    • Events, Fairs & Exhibitions
    • Give Me Five!
    • History
    • Quill & Pad
    • Round Table
    • The Naked Watchmaker
    • Thoughts & Opinion
    • Video
    • WatchCharts
    • Wrist Watching
    • A. Lange & Söhne
    • AHCI
    • Akrivia
    • Andersen Genève
    • Alexandre Meerson
    • Andreas Strehler
    • Angelus
    • Antoine Martin
    • Antoine Preziuso
    • Armin Strom
    • Arnold & Son
    • Audemars Piguet
      • Royal Oak Offshore
    • Bélier
    • Bell & Ross
    • Blancpain
    • Bovet
    • Breguet
    • Bremont
    • Breitling
    • Bulgari
    • Carl F. Bucherer
    • Cartier
    • Chanel
    • Chopard
    • Christiaan Van Der Klaauw
    • Christophe Claret
    • Chronoswiss
    • Clocks
    • Corum
    • Cyrus
    • Czapek & Cie
    • De Bethune
    • de Grisogono
    • Derek Pratt
    • Dior
    • Divers' Watches
    • Eberhard
    • Emmanuel Bouchet
    • Fabergé
    • Ferdinand Berthoud
    • Fiona Krüger
    • F.P. Journe
    • Franck Muller
    • Garrick
    • Gérald Genta
    • Girard-Perregaux
    • Glashütte Original
    • GoS
    • Graff
    • Graham
    • Greubel Forsey
    • Grieb & Benzinger
    • Grönefeld
    • H. Moser & Cie
    • Habring2
    • Hajime Asaoka
    • Harry Winston
    • Hautlence
    • Hermès
    • Hublot
    • HYT
    • Independents
    • IWC
    • Jaeger-LeCoultre
    • Jaquet Droz
    • Jean Daniel Nicolas
    • Jean Dunand
    • Kari Voutilainen
    • Kees Engelbarts
    • Kobold
    • Konstantin Chaykin
    • Kudoke
    • Ladies watches
    • Lang & Heyne
    • Laurent Ferrier
    • Linde Werdelin
    • Louis Moinet
    • Louis Vuitton
    • Ludovic Ballouard
    • Manufacture Royale
    • Maurice Lacroix
    • MB&F
    • McGonigle
    • Ming Watches
    • Montblanc
    • Moritz Grossmann
    • Nomos Glashütte
    • Ochs und Junior
    • Officine Panerai
    • Omega
    • Parmigiani
    • Patek Philippe
    • Paul Gerber
    • Philippe Dufour
    • Piaget
    • Pocket watches
    • Rebellion
    • Ressence
    • RGM
    • Richard Mille
    • Roger Dubuis
    • Roger W Smith
    • Roland Iten
    • Rolex
    • Romain Gauthier
    • Romain Jerome
    • Sarpaneva
    • Schwarz-Etienne
    • Seiko
    • Silberstein
    • Singer Reimagined
    • Soviet / Eastern Europe watches
    • Speake-Marin
    • Struthers
    • Tag Heuer
    • Tudor
    • Tutima
    • Ulysse Nardin
    • Urban Jürgensen
    • Urwerk
    • Vacheron Constantin
    • Van Cleef & Arpels
    • Vianney Halter
    • Vintage
    • Wempe Glashütte
    • Zenith
  • Luxury, Experiences, Science & Nature
    • Arts
    • Book reviews
    • Cars
      • Porsche
    • Fashion & Grooming
    • Jewelry
    • Nature
    • Photo Captions
    • Photography
    • Science
    • Shoes
    • Sports
    • Technology
    • Travel
    • Wining, Dining and Cigars
    • Writing instruments
      • Caran d’Ache
      • Grayson Tighe
      • Montblanc
      • Montegrappa
  • General
    • Featured
    • Highlights
© Copyright - Quill & Pad - Enfold Theme by Kriesi
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Do not sell my personal information.
Cookie SettingsAccept
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
CookieDurationDescription
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT