Why I Bought It: Grönefeld 1941 Remontoire
If you’re a watch enthusiast, you know that there are some watches you fall for the moment you see them. Sometimes that initial infatuation passes and you move on to the next temporary obsession, but then there are those instances in which the more you see, talk about, and learn about a piece and its origins the more you resolve to save up to buy one.
For me, the Grönefeld 1941 Remontoire was one of the latter.
Why I bought it: beginning with a brief history lesson
Once upon a time (ca. AD 700, to be more exact) there was an Irish Benedictine monk named Plechelm who traveled to the kingdom of Frisia (now the Netherlands) and founded a church dedicated to Pope Silvester in what is now the town of Oldenzaal. Around AD 950 Plechelm was canonized by Pope Agapetus II, and the church was rededicated in St. Plechelm’s honor when his remains were returned there circa AD 954.
Around 1150, construction of the current basilica of St. Plechelm began, and a tower (most relevant to our story) was added around 1240, heightened in the 1500s, and in 1913 ultimately equipped with its current clock made by Royal Eijsbouts. It features a 30-second remontoire mechanism that protects the clock’s escapement from the massive weights used to drive the movement, which jump the clock’s hands each half-minute to break any accumulated ice.
Of course, someone had to maintain the clock and its Gillett and Johnston carillon added in 1930. That was a fellow by the name of Johan Grönefeld.
After Johan’s death his son Sjef took on this responsibility. As boys, his sons Bart and Tim grew up within earshot of the clock’s chimes and received a number of stern warnings from Sjef during their visits within the tower to stay well clear of the large swinging blades of the clock’s remontoire, which in particular made a strong impression on the younger son, Tim.
Little wonder, then, that upon deciding to launch their independent watchmaking business, Tim and Bart were immediately inspired to begin thinking about how a regulated remontoire mechanism similar to that of the Plechelm clock’s might be incorporated into a watch. And in time – and with the collaboration of brilliant movement designer Andreas Strehler – Baselworld 2016 saw the introduction of the 1941 Remontoire, so designated in honor of Sjef’s birth year.
I was immediately taken by the watch when I saw it, but once I heard its origin story, and especially as I’d made the climb up the St. Plechelm tower myself a few years prior, I knew I’d eventually have to own one.
How the Grönefeld 1941 Remontoire fits in my collection
In my pal Terry’s collection taxonomy, this one is very definitely a patronage piece: one purchased to recognize the superb work being done by today’s best independent watchmakers and to support them in their creative efforts.
For me, it’s also intended to be a regular daily wearer in the same vein as my recently purchased Hajime Asaoka Tsunami. It’s for that reason that I opted for a stainless steel case and also why I ultimately decided against adding any of the extremely tasty engraved or enameled dials from Kari Voutilainen’s Comblemine dial-making operation in favor of the simpler silver dial offered at the watch’s 2016 introduction.
Why I love the Grönefeld 1941 Remontoire
The story is great, and the makers are superb fellows and big talents, but things get even more interesting when you flip the watch over and see the back for the first time.
I’ve seen a couple of reviewers criticize Caliber G-05 as too busy looking for their tastes, but for me it’s just fantastic looking and a real show of mechanical and finishing virtuosity. The combination of frosting, graining, snailing, perlage, black polishing, and other techniques I’m probably missing are a feast for the eyes. And the shapes, including the several dual-spoked wheels and the bridges shaped like the “bell gable” roofs of Dutch houses, invite lengthy and repeated contemplation.
The brothers’ use of stainless steel as the material for their movement bridges, while adding to the difficulty of finishing, yields a distinctive look and in my instance matches up perfectly with the tone of my steel case.
The “1941” case style (also used in the newly introduced Principia line) is itself another accomplishment, as in my opinion it is markedly more sophisticated than the first-generation case design used on the brothers’ One Hertz and Parallax Tourbillon.
In the photo above, check out the swooping shapes of the lugs, including the shoulder that connects the side nearest the strap to the narrower portion of the lug that is in turn mirrored by a corresponding soft shoulder on the bezel of the watch. It also took me a little while to notice the parallel character grooves cut into the case band at the heights of the inside edges of the lug cutouts; these are not necessary, but quite elegant and effective in unifying the look of the case and lugs.
Zooming in on the crown, we see the symbol of the Grönefelds’ life and work, the etched “Horological Brothers” logo. It does seem at times as if Tim and Bart are joined at the hip! But their closeness and devotion to each other and their families is a big part of the appeal of their enterprise.
Even the buckle mirrors the design language of the rest of the watch with its bold curves and distinct shoulders. And while I’d normally say that one of the weakest compliments you can give a watch is “nice strap,” the antiqued blue strap that the brothers chose for delivery of my watch is really killer and deserves a mention.
Mechanically, of course, this watch is all about the constant force mechanism itself, and I like that it is prominently featured. On the movement side, the remontoire spring cage and its associated gears seen at the right side of the photo below glide smoothly to the next position each eight seconds.
On the dial side the regulator with its bridge integrated into the 9 o’clock index whizzes around on the same eight-second schedule, and on the same interval the minute hand moves forward by 8/60 of a minute in the same way that St. Plechelm’s tower clock hands move every 30 seconds – although in the case of my watch, I’m very hopeful that there will not be any accumulated ice to dislodge!
Finally, there’s nothing quite like buying an independent watch! That’s especially true when the makers present it in person and a good friend is there to capture the moment.
There’s obviously a lot to love about this watch, and I’m finding it tough to generate any real complaints! If I had to come up with a thought or two, they might look as follows.
- Those nooks and crannies in the lugs that lend such visual interest also tend to accumulate schmutz over time; by no means a big deal as seen by the naked eye, but as a macro photographer I notice these things.
- While we’re on the subject of the lugs, they’re very clever in that they are attached by screws from the interior of the case; but that leaves small grooves between the case and lug that tend to catch tiny fibers.
- The 36-hour power reserve is adequate, but at least on my example when the power gets low the constant force mechanism begins to misfire a bit, operating more frequently than each eight seconds and seeming not to lock fully into position in between. As a result, I find that I need to be vigilant about ensuring that the watch maintains a decent state of wind.
- This one is strictly on me, but I do occasionally wish I’d picked the warmer red gold case!
Is it right for you?
I’ve obviously voted with my wallet, but is this watch one that you should consider? I’d say thumbs up if the following apply to you.
- You’re a fan of independent watchmaking and want to own one of today’s leading examples of inventive, beautiful watch design and execution.
- Your horological interests tend at least in part toward innovations that are meant to improve timekeeping, and this example of constant-force movement design complements other approaches (e.g., tourbillon or fusée and chain) you own or study.
- Like me, you find the personal story of the Grönefeld family and the importance of this particular mechanism in their lives compelling.
- You just want to see that regulator whiz around each eight seconds!
On the other hand, you might want to leave the enjoyment to me and the other owners of this watch if this applies to you.
- The remontoire mechanism seems a bit too esoteric to be the foundation of a timepiece.
- You haven’t yet caught the independent bug.
- For whatever reason the aesthetics just don’t grab you.
- Your collection focuses on other themes and this piece wouldn’t fit in.
If you are inclined to act, you should probably do so fairly soon as only 188 examples of this movement will be made, and the great majority are already delivered or spoken for.
Let me know your thoughts in the comments section, and as always happy hunting!
For more information, please visit www.gronefeld.com/collection/1941-remontoire.
Quick Facts Grönefeld 1941 Remontoire
Case: 39.5 x 10.5 mm with replaceable screwed-on lugs; available in 5N red gold, unplated palladium white gold, and stainless steel
Dial and hands: multiple dial options available, including solid silver dial with faceted applied baton indices and a variety of bespoke engraved and enameled dial designs from Comblemine; printed minute track, seconds, and signature; blued-steel lancette hands
Movement: manually wound Caliber G-05 with stainless steel bridges; free-sprung overcoil balance; several jewels set in gold chatons; 36-hour power reserve; 21,600 vph/3 Hz frequency
Functions: hours, minutes, hacking subsidiary seconds
Production years: 2016 onward
Limitation: total of 188 examples to be made
Price: stainless steel with silver dial €44,900; €49,500 in red gold; €50,850 in white gold; (all excluding taxes)
Premium: bespoke guilloche dial starts at €7,500 and enameling adds an additional €5,000 and up
You may also enjoy:
Grönefeld 1941 Remontoire In The Horological House Of Orange
Copernicus, Alignment Shift, And The Grönefeld Parallax Tourbillon: A Nerd Story
Why The Grönefeld 1941 Remontoire Won Best Men’s Watch At The 2016 Grand Prix d’Horlogerie de Genève
Leave a ReplyWant to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!
Dear GaryG ,
Great article and huge congrats with getting this gorgeous piece of dutchpride , i allways love to hear and read about how other watch collectors think about this watch . i just love the brand and there owners tim and bart are such fun and down to earth people . The remontaire is a true piece of art imho and i cant wait to strap one on the wrist soon (thelongwait?)
Again thanks for this great article .
Many thanks for the kind words — and I know from my own Long Wait that it’s pretty excruciating!
Completely agree with your thoughts on the Brothers and looking forward to hearing when you take delivery.
Congratulations, great choice! I own the red gold version, with blue enamel fishscale guilloche dial, and I couldn’t be happier. That said, I find this stainless steel version to be quite appealing in its boldness and relative simplicity. BTW, I remember that when I first saw the watch, and especially the movement, I thought the listed price was probably an error. I was happy to learn that it wasn’t.
Thanks! I’m sure that the red gold with blue enamel dial is absolutely killer — congrats. While none of these sorts of watches is inexpensive, I agree with you that there are a number of three-hand indie watches that are richly priced by comparison. All the better for us collectors!
Thanks for your another thoughtful article, Gary.
If I had the budget, this watch is simply a no-brainer for me.
Instead, choosing which model will be really hard…
SS/Salmon dial or RG/Rhodium dial or any bespoke dials…
I agree with you — choosing is really hard! Some of those bespoke dials are unbelievable and I don’t think anyone would go wrong by choosing one.
And, thanks for the kind words on the article!
The movement finish is sublime.
Agree — I don’t think that Bart and Tim get the credit they deserve for the quality of the finishing on their watches — and on steel components at that!
There’s almost an element of ‘chiaroscuro’ to it, a little like Moser’s black edition 341 calibre. I love that, very different from the norm.
Gary, I have the SS with Kari’s guilloche + blue enamel dial. The antiqued-blue strap lost its stain rather quickly (I wear the watch every week), so I replaced it. In the end, an antiqued-gray J Rousseau strap did the trick, as it introduced contrast against the dial and some warmth against the case. My hunch is that you will appreciate your SS case more if you find a different contrast with the strap. BTW, I hate the crevices where the lugs attach to the case and have considered writing The Brothers to request a fiber removal tool!
I think a Grönefeld branded fiber removal tool would be just the thing to have!
Great thoughts on contrasting straps — thanks, and I’ll now start checking out other colors. Congrats on what I’m sure is a gorgeous piece — wear and enjoy!
This may sound cheeky, but I’m genuinely curious: is there a sufficient gap to use dental tape (as opposed to floss) to clean it?
Strange, in almost two years I cannot recall having seen a fiber trapped by the lugs of my 1941. And I usually wear long sleeves.
Regarding power reserve, this watch is definitely an everyday winder, which is actually the preference of many manual watch owners. Some of us enjoy the routine of winding every morning (and unwinding every evening..).
Your lugs must be snugged up more tightly than Peter’s and mine! Not at all an issue unless you are an anal macro shooter like myself, I suppose.
I do enjoy winding my watches, and have no problem doing so on a daily basis — I mention the need in my article primarily for completeness, and also because the remontoire does get a bit fussy at lower levels of mainspring power. I’m going to ask the Brothers about this when I see them next week — may be that a small tweak is needed to my particular watch.
Very happy to hear that you are enjoying your 1941 Remontoire!
Great article about an amazing piece of wrist art. The Grönefeld 1941 is the perfect size and just a pleasure to to stare at. The strap may well be the most comfortable one I have ever had on my wrist. To top it off the buying experience is second to none. #IndependentsRule
Independents rule indeed! Agree with you 100 percent on your praise for this watch and the buying experience — will hope to have a chance to compare watches with you sometime soon!
Great article and beautiful high res pictures. I now am even more excited about my June trip to Odenzaal to pick up my bespoke version. It appears I will have some virtual friends to share it with in the form of the Quill and Pad community! My 17 yr old son is a videographer and will be joining me and I expect will create a memorable video as he has done with our family trips the past few years.
What is your feeling about personalizing the watch such as with discrete initials on one of the bridges (I think Lange does that). Can’t decide if it is tacky or devalues it. I suspect my namesake son will have the watch after me so am not too concerned about resale.
If I may add my two cents: I do not think it is tacky in the least. I have personalized many of my own watches in some way. Engraving your initials sounds perfect to me – particularly if you are keen to pass the watch on. And I’m sure your enjoyment of the watch would be even greater that way!
Hi Bill — sorry for the delay in responding! I very much like the idea of discreet personalization — I’ve seen a Dufour Simplicity with the first owner’s initials on the balance cock, for example, and particularly if the watch is to be passed down within a family I think your initials or another unique marking would be a great addition.
We will plan to follow your adventure! Best, Gary
Old post but no one answered your question, because you answered it yourself,if you are wondering of it makes you a bit of a self gas inhaler.., I think you know you who you are (:
I have to admit, I’ve known about this watch but was indifferent because of the casualness of it (dial text, indices) until recently when I saw a video of the movement and its mechanical art in motion. I don’t think any watch has made my jaw drop like that since the Datograph.
I’ve not taken the plunge to independents before. What is the buying experience like? How long (roughly) was the wait? TY
Sorry for the delay in getting back to you! Dealing with the brothers is a treat — they are (as you might imagine) passionate about their work and eager to show a potential buyer all of the various options. In the US (and I suspect elsewhere in the world) Grönefeld is also represented by an authorized dealer (Cellini in NY) if you prefer that path.
The Grönefelds are the best source of information on the current lead time for this watch — I waited about 11 months, which suited me quite well as I needed to save up!
The somewhat casual nature of this piece was actually a big attractor for me as it means that I can wear it on a broader range of occasions — and as you say the mechanical wizardry is truly impressive!
Gary, as always thanks for another Great article. I love the work of the Gronefeld Brothers, and now with their new Principia Automatic, a lot easier to access as well. Your article certainly helps understand the history, the brand, their philosophy, and their watches a lot more. Thanks.
Thanks for commenting, Kunal! That new Principia is really lovely, and the self-winding movement is both attractive and practical. I’m delighted to have the Remontoire, but if I didn’t I’d be looking very hard at the Principia right now…
As of three days ago, I am now the proud owner/wearer of possibly the very last 1941 Remontoire to come off the “production line” (read: watchmaker’s bench). What an amazing piece of horological art it is too!
I still hold fond memories of sipping beers with Tim, Bart and Kari at Big Bamboo in Shanghai many years ago. Have always regretted not getting a selfie with them. But now at least I own a watch which contains a little bit of all three gentlemen’s workmanship embedded within it. (OK, Mr V probably doesn’t turn the wheel of the rose engine himself, but you know what I mean…)